Online ordering powered by Seamless
318 WEST 23RD STREET (23rd St. between 8th Ave. & 9th Ave.)(646) 486-7400
Minimum order of $15.00 is required for delivery
Delivery estimate is 40 - 55 min (more info)
Seamless allows you to enjoy convenient online ordering from the best local restaurants. If you're ordering for the first time, start your order by entering your address to the right. Return users log in here.
Print this menu
Recommended dressings are mixed in unless alternate dressing selected.
Read more
Video.
Hide
In the early 1900’s, while working in the salumerias of Little Italy, Patsy Lancieri perfected “New York Style Pizza”. In 1933, he opened the city’s first pizzeria restaurant on 118th Street and First Avenue, thus establishing himself as New York’s foremost pizza baker and inspiring scores of imitators.
Over sixty years later, Patsy’s Pizzeria still proudly serves famous recipe old world style pizza throughout the city. Visit us at one of our six locations and see why Patsy's Pizzeria has been a favorite for so many decades!
Pizza—Featuring fifteen different toppings in two different sizes: large or small
Insalata Siciliana—Green salad with mozzarella, black olives, capers, tomatoes, roasted peppers, carrots, anchovies, and artichokes with homemade Italian dressing
Penne alla Vodka—Penne in cream and tomato sauce with vodka and pancetta
Penne Bolognese—Penne with homemade zesty meat sauce
Pappardelle alla Toscanese—Fresh wide ribbon pasta with sundried tomatoes, wild mushrooms, marsala wine, aged parmigiano and pecorino cheese in a cream sauce
Not in our delivery zone? Please visit one of our other Patsy’s Pizzeria locations in Manhattan:
Patsys Pizzeria (60th Street)
206 East 60th Street
(212) 688-9707
Patsy’s Pizzeria (34th Street)
509 3rd Avenue
(212) 689-7500
Patsy’s University Place
67 University Place
(212) 533-3500
This place has the best pizza on here. It's delicious. Arrives fast. And hot. ENJOY!
Posted 8 hours ago by Bryan M.
Pizza is super yummy...only once has it come overcooked...not so yummy.
Posted 4 days ago by Rebecca T.
We waited an hour and a half for our food and the pasta was overcooked! Two stars only because the insalata siciliana was yummy.
Posted a month ago by Myra C.
Asked for well done bottom crust, and it still arrived VERY undercooked -- dough was soft and mushy in the middle of the pie. UNACCEPTABLE.
Posted 2 months ago by Phil C.
Food has generally gone downhill here and delivery is mediocre at best.
Posted 5 months ago by Jan P.
Fantastic. Excellent bolognese and the cheesecake was sophisticated and fabulous. Expensive for a delivered lunch, but great and worth the treat.
Posted 5 months ago by Avery C.
BEST CUSTOMER SERVICE I HAVE SEEN!!!!
Posted 5 months ago by Evan E.
Arrived 2 hours later...pizza was cold.
Posted 6 months ago by Tamsin Y.
YUCK!!!! lousy pizza, a really boring horrible crust, and the salad came wilted with a disgusting watery dressing that was like something from a prison cafeteria. It's so sad how so many restaurants in nyc get by on the common crappy level , and people think it's great because they've gotten used to it. What happened to a genuinely good nyc pizza? It ain't here, that's sure..
Posted 8 months ago by christina k.
This pizza is definitely above and beyond a regular pizzeria's. it's not greasy, the sauce is really flavorful and the cheese is nice and fresh. I highly recommend it.
Posted 9 months ago by Aaron S.
Pizza is great! So is the penne vodka. Not your traditional NY pizza, but still very good. Delivery times arent great (especially during peak hours) but its still worth the wait. Definitely a solid option, and worth trying.
Posted 9 months ago by Sahil M.
Patsy's is consistently good, I highly recommend the small pizza and the insalada romana. They tend to put a lot of dressing on the salad, however the fresh parm cheese they point on top really makes it. Although it is a bit overpriced, it is always a good meal.
Posted 9 months ago by Alex S.
All the pastas are great. Pizza crust is crispy & delicous. Fairly quick on the delivery but could be better.
Posted 9 months ago by amandarris g.
Large portions. Slow delivery
Posted 9 months ago by Katie L.
Outstanding pizza, period. Pepperoni is thick and fresh. Basil is very fresh. The mozzerella is sweet and well distributed. Cannoli is literally the best I have ever had -- ricotta is very smooth and sweet. Sometimes delivery comes slowly and the pizza is not as hot as I would want.
Posted 9 months ago by Paul L.
love the pizza!! somethings is always off with the salads (too much dressing, too little, etc)
Posted 10 months ago by haley s.
HORRIBLE SERVICE. After waiting over an hour for my delivery (which was quoted as 25-40 min.), I called Patsy's and was transferred to 3 different people. None of whom could help me. Turns out "the computer lost my order." Not a good enough reason. Their solution was even worse..."we'll make it right away and get it to you." No offer of a discount, and they balked at the idea of one when I asked for one.
Posted 11 months ago by Julie T.
great quality and great food.
Posted a year ago by Pamela P.
Late 20mins, almost every time.
Posted a year ago by Mario D.
Our go to place for thin crust, brick oven pizza. Excellent pepperoni. Insalata mista is always fresh and tasty. Pastas are also good. I like their spinach raviolis and rigatoni bolognese. This is a great place to order for a large crowd since they offer family size portions.
Posted a year ago by Charlotte T.
this pizza is ok, maybe better than average but not a good value.
Posted a year ago by Kristin S.
Always great pizza. New York style.
Posted 2 years ago by Helene D.
pasta dishes are very good
Posted 2 years ago by bob s.
Delivery is prompt and food is always as good as when we eat in the restaurant. Try the pizza with ricotta and garlic- excellent. And oh, don't forget the tiramisu!!
Posted 2 years ago by Clarabelle R.
Food and delivery are excellent, if expensive. Pizza, Insalata Mista, fried zucchini, pasta fagioli, bolognese -- all excellent in my opinion. My one big complaint is that their "specials" -- chicken parm, spaghetti and meatballs, chicken marsala -- ARE NOT on the seamless web menu and therefore impossible to order. I have to call for these items! PLEASE PUT THE CHICKEN PARMESAN, SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS, AND MARSALA ON THE SEAMLESS MENU!
Posted 2 years ago by Todd H.
Always great Italian food. Fast delivery.
Posted 2 years ago by Allen G.
Excellent but pricey pizza. Fresh ingredients. Bonus: pizza reheats pretty well in the oven.
Posted 3 years ago by Chris M.
Only select user reviews are published on Seamless. All user-submitted ratings contribute to Patsy's 23rd's overall Seamless rating, but we manually screen all reviews and only publish those that are relevant and helpful. Tips for getting your review published »
Above content provided by restaurant.
Order online from Patsy's 23rd by entering your address below. Online ordering powered by Seamless.com.
Return users log in here.
Click a menu item to add it to your order.
Back to top